ESPU is OpposingHawaiiHB1902

March 6, 2016 Re: Opposing HB 1902

Dear Hawaii State Legislators,

We are writing to you to let you know of our opposition to HB 1902 because it won’t do what you say it will.  You shouldn’t write any legislation that would allow law enforcement to sexually assault or abuse vulnerable populations in any way and that’s what HB 1902 proposes to do in section 12(5).  In the same section you have pledged to imprison prostitutes and sex trafficking victims and take from them $500-1000 of the money they have earned through prostitution.  It is precisely because of legislation like this that sex trafficking victims and prostitutes don’t have access to equal protection under the law or the due process protections of the justice system in the first place.  Having this poorly crafted legislation conflate both groups together under the guise of providing security and protection is already a failed policy approach.

When you write laws to allow police to have sex with sex trafficking victims and simultaneously have your state profit from the prostitution of trafficking victims and prostitutes it is clear that lessening sex trafficking is not your priority.  In fact, by your own laws, you are guilty of writing criminal laws which cause your state to engage in the criminal behavior of profiting from prostitution.

Here in Alaska, we have spent lots of time educating legislators about disastrous results of this same type of failed policy.  Now Alaska Senator Berta Gardner (  907-465-3873) has updated language in her Alaska Senate Bill 21 to instead incentivize the right behavior both of law enforcement and our community members by altering the prostitution statute so that a person can’t be charged with prostitution as a result of reporting that they were the victim or witness of a serious felony.

For further policy considerations, please make yourselves aware of the Erotic Service Providers Legal, Education and Research Projects Policy Agenda for 2016:  

It has a long list of possible legislative avenues for Hawaii to pursue when addressing protection for people in the sex trade.


Maxine Doogan

President, Community United for Safety and Protection

Terra Burns

Vice President, Community United for Safety and Protection

Community United for Safety and Protection (CUSP)

Community United for Safety and Protection (CUSP)